| Criteria |
Weight |
Score |
| Bad |
Good |
Distinction |
Excellence |
| Background and Problem Statement |
5 |
unclear/not relevant |
clear and based on unit/department |
real life and based on directorate/BU |
real life and based on BINUS Group or National |
| Rerefence |
5 |
relevant reference > 2 & should be uploaded to KM Portal |
relevant reference > 5 & should be uploaded to KM Portal |
relevant reference > 8 & should be uploaded to KM Portal |
relevant reference > 11 & should be uploaded to KM Portal |
| Plan |
10 |
not feasible |
clear but no prototype |
prototype and partially ready to implemented |
prototype and fully ready to implemented |
| Risk |
10 |
not defined |
well identified but no solution |
well identified but least solution |
well identified and great solution |
| Output |
20 |
unclear output |
well defined and impact to unit/department |
well defined and impact to Business Unit/Directorate |
well defined and impact on national/BINUS Group |
| Novelty |
20 |
already exist with little improvement |
already exist with moderate improvement |
already exist with heavy improvement |
new to BINUS Group/national |
| Implementation |
20 |
not implemented |
partially implemented |
mostly implemented |
fully implemented |
| Presentation |
10 |
unclear/ not follow presentation format |
clear/ follow the presentation format |
(good) + additional data and example |
(distinction) + presentation delivered well |
